Gretel Kutan
Luxury Hospitality Projects
EMEA · Globally Flexible
Perspectives · VIII

Not Every Profitable Offer Is Good for the Brand

In a restaurant or beach club, the offer calendar says more about the venue than its marketing does. The real question is who is accountable for what it says.

A quiet Tuesday, a half-empty terrace, and someone suggests a bottomless brunch. It will fill the room. It will also tell every guest who walks in exactly what kind of place this is.

In F&B, the decisions that shape how a venue is seen are rarely taken by marketing. They are taken in revenue meetings, on quiet days and in the week a strong day finally starts to sell out. A Ladies Day, because it is working somewhere else. A brunch, because it fills the room. On paper both make perfect commercial sense. But every offer also tells the market something: what kind of place this is, who it is for and what people should expect when they arrive.

Success creates its own version of the same pressure, and I have written before about how minimum spends creep up once a venue is in demand. The quiet-period offer is the less noticed half of the problem. It is made in good faith, usually to protect the month, and it rarely passes through anyone whose job is to ask what it says.

That was one of the biggest shifts for me when I moved from brand and marketing closer to business development. Brand is not only protected by marketing. It is protected, or weakened, by the commercial choices the business makes every day, usually under pressure, when the immediate number is louder than the longer-term consequence.

When F&B marketing is treated as content, social and the odd event, the commercial calendar quietly becomes the real brand strategy. The Instagram feed says one thing. The brunch package, the minimum spend and the Thursday promotion say another, and the guest believes the second.

Not every piece of business that makes money strengthens the brand.

The same applies to partnerships. Fashion and luxury brands have activated inside beach clubs and restaurants for over a decade. What has changed is the scale and the sophistication. The principle has not: a partnership works when it makes the guest experience more distinctive, not when it turns the venue into a billboard. If the only output is a photo opportunity and a press mention, it is underperforming, however good it looks.

This matters more now because the competition for the local luxury audience is getting sharper. Major hotel groups are building F&B as a specialist capability, with dedicated divisions and restaurant brands of their own, and they are competing for the same people independent restaurant groups have always had to win. A hotel restaurant can no longer rely on the guest upstairs, and every offer will be read against a better alternative down the road.

So the useful question is not whether marketing is producing enough. It is whether anyone is accountable for what the venue is saying through everything it sells. In practice, every new offer is judged on what it says about the venue as well as on what it will take on the day. Revenue management, programming and marketing work from one view of who the venue is for. Partnerships are designed from inside the operation rather than dropped on top of it.

Many operators try to solve this with a hire, but a marketing job title is not a strategy. Without a decision about who owns the offer, a new marketer inherits the calendar rather than shaping it.

The venues that hold their positioning for years are rarely the ones with the best campaigns. They are the ones where someone has the authority to say “Yes, this will make money, but it is wrong for us”, and the business accepts the answer.

· · ·
Gretel Kutan
← Back to Perspectives